Response to "Vlad Sokhin's Photos of Haiti's Child Servants"

Lawrence Kaplan - May 26 2013, 12:38 PM

Response to "Vlad Sokhin's Photos of Haiti's Child Servants"

Mr. Sokhin has disgraced the honorable profession of photojournalism.

His lies to the NYTimes Lens Blog about the source of his Restavek photos and his deceitful narrative that he gave to journalist Deborah Sontag to accompany the photographs is reprehensible.

His slander of Mr. Lesli Zoe Petit-Phar is disgusting, self-serving, and probably in false pursuit of a Pulitzer.

As President of a 501c3 organization working in the slums of Cite Soleil, Port au Prince since the 2010 earthquake, I've known Zoe for over three years and he is a good man. With regard to the child in question, the Petit-Phars took her into their home four years ago when her orphanage closed.

Yes, she eats at their family table.

Yes, she sleeps in a rooms with beds and other furniture.

Yes, she goes to the bathroom "outside," in an enclosed facility with a shower, Western toilet and basin.

Yes, she does light house work, as most Haitian children are expected to do, but the Petit-Phars hire a Haitian woman to cook, wash and clean.

Granted she isn't treated nearly as well as their own 5-year-old daughter, but the Petit-Phars are not Restavek slave owners.

The most concerning part of Mr. Sokhin's disgraceful behavior is that his deception may deflect attention away from the real issue: 250,000 Haitian children living as Restaveks, physically and mentally abused, in a system of slavery where the "owners" pets are far better treated.

SHAME ON YOU, Mr. Sorkin

Related Article:

Restavec in Haiti, Shedding a New Light

In Haiti, a RESTAVEC is the ultimate have-not in a society of have-nots. There is a new set of shameful Haiti restavec photos that has just surfaced...

REPLY to this message

Return to Message List

Messages and comments from our readers...

Both her parents are haitian descent but not her...

Both her parents are haitian descent but not her, then she is not their bioligical kid? According the haitian 's constitution even her can claim her...

72 Gourdes for 1 U.S. Dollar in Haiti, record low for the Haitian currency compared to the Dollar 72 Gourdes for 1 U.S. Dollar in Haiti, record low for the Haitian currency compared to the Dollar

The Haitian currency has hit a record low compared the U.S. Dollar these days... As of Saturday, Oct 13 2018, you need 72.50 gourdes for one U.S...

International Monetary Fund (IMF) chief says before Naomi Osaka women's tennis lived in the shadow of the men's game in Japan International Monetary Fund (IMF) chief says before Naomi Osaka women's tennis lived in the shadow of the men's game in Japan

Christine Lagarde, chief of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) said before Haitian-Japanese tennis player Naomi Osaka's shock the world when she...

Haitian Photo Stories...

Look at the FEAR in the eyes of this Haitian woman during a Street Protest in Haiti Look at the FEAR in the eyes of this Haitian woman during a Street Protest in Haiti

They say a picture is worth a thousand words... Look at the FEAR in the eyes of this poor Haitian woman during a street protest, captured by the...

PHOTO: Haiti - The Most Beautiful Picture of Citadelle Laferrière PHOTO: Haiti - The Most Beautiful Picture of Citadelle Laferrière

Wow... Look at this photo... Citadelle Laferrière in Milot Haiti - Isn't this most beautiful picture of Citadelle Laferrière you have ever...

PHOTO: The New Haitian Army Corps of Engineers at work after the Port-de-Paix Haiti Earthquake PHOTO: The New Haitian Army Corps of Engineers at work after the Port-de-Paix Haiti Earthquake

Look at this photo... Soldiers from the new Haitian Army Corps of Engineers are working very hard to clear the rubble from the homes destroyed by...